Trump Moves to Block His Own Spy Chief Hearing — Senate Republicans Push Back

Before 4 a.m. on Wednesday, while attending the G7 Summit in France, President Trump posted on Truth Social that he was cancelling the Senate confirmation hearing for his own nominee to lead U.S. intelligence. The hearing was scheduled to begin at 2 p.m. that same day.

Senate Republicans decided to proceed anyway.

Senate Defies Trump as Clayton Hearing Goes Forward

Senator Tom Cotton of Arkansas, the Republican chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee, said the hearing for Jay Clayton as Director of National Intelligence would continue as planned.

"Jay Clayton is a pending nominee before the Intelligence Committee," Cotton wrote on X. "We will proceed with his hearing as scheduled unless the president directs him not to appear or withdraws his nomination."

Senate Majority Leader John Thune of South Dakota told reporters the chamber would "take it a day at a time" until there was more clarity on the White House's position, according to reporting from The Daily Caller. When asked why he believed Trump was attempting to halt Clayton's hearing, Thune replied: "Good question."

Clayton — the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York — had been nominated to permanently lead the Office of the Director of National Intelligence after Trump's earlier temporary pick, Bill Pulte, drew bipartisan criticism on Capitol Hill.

📰 Related: Senate Democrats Let FISA Expire Saturday — Blocking Surveillance Law Over Bill Pulte Appointment

The FISA Complication Trump Created

The timing matters because it is not just about Clayton.

Section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act — which permits spy agencies to collect the communications of targeted foreigners abroad without a warrant — expired on June 12.

National security officials in both parties have long described it as one of the most important tools in the U.S. intelligence apparatus.

The lapse occurred because Democrats refused to vote for reauthorization as long as Pulte, who has no intelligence experience, remained in the acting DNI role.

Republicans and Democrats had informally agreed: confirm Clayton quickly, remove Pulte, restore FISA.

The hearing had been scheduled within hours of Clayton's nomination precisely to move him through the process before June 19, the date Trump said Pulte would formally assume the acting role.

Trump's overnight post broke that arrangement. He said he was now demanding that FISA reauthorization be linked to the SAVE America Act — a Republican voter-registration bill requiring proof of U.S. citizenship at the polls that failed in the Senate earlier this month — and also conditioned Clayton's confirmation on the Senate first confirming Jamie McDonald as a U.S. Attorney.

As NPR reported, Trump also accused Republicans of falling into a trap set by Democrats, arguing the party moved so quickly on Clayton that Pulte would be pushed aside before Democrats were obligated to vote on FISA.

📰 Related: Trump Arrives at G7 With Insults Already on the Table

The Risk Inside the White House's Own Position

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer directly challenged the framing. "Trump is twisting himself up in knots and jumping through hoops to make it impossible to reauthorize FISA right now, and he is embarrassing his Republican colleagues in the process," Schumer said, according to ABC News. "Trump can blame Democrats all he wants, but no one is going to believe him."

The critique embedded in that statement is pointed: it was Trump who nominated Pulte, and it was Pulte's appointment — not Democratic obstruction — that caused Section 702 to lapse in the first place. The Senate had a path out of the impasse. Trump's 4 a.m. post closed it, at least temporarily.

Pulte himself has no national security experience. He currently directs the Federal Housing Finance Agency, where he used his platform to call for investigations into perceived opponents of the president, including Federal Reserve official Lisa Cook and New York Democratic Attorney General Letitia James.

PBS NewsHour reported that Clayton would succeed outgoing DNI Tulsi Gabbard, who resigned last month citing her husband's cancer diagnosis. His fast-tracked hearing date had been set within hours of his nomination.

📰 Related: Trump Says US-Iran Deal Will Be Signed Sunday — Iran Says "Not Tomorrow"

🤖 AI Generated Image

What Happens If Clayton Is Delayed

The question now is what Trump does if Clayton appears and the hearing proceeds.

A nomination withdrawal would return the U.S. intelligence community to indefinite leadership under Pulte — a scenario that both Republican and Democratic senators have worked to avoid.

FISA Section 702 would remain expired, without Congressional authorization, for an indeterminate period. The intelligence gathering it underpins would continue under temporary legal authority only.

The Senate had tried to thread this needle with speed. Trump's intervention from France made speed unavailable. What comes next depends on whether Cotton and Thune can hold their ground — and whether Trump ultimately decides the leverage is worth the cost of leaving a key national security tool lapsed.

Key Takeaways

• Trump posted on Truth Social before 4 a.m. on June 17, from the G7 Summit in France, announcing the cancellation of Jay Clayton's DNI confirmation hearing.

• Senate Intelligence Committee Chairman Tom Cotton said the hearing would proceed as scheduled at 2 p.m. unless Trump formally withdrew Clayton or directed him not to appear.

• FISA Section 702 — a key warrantless surveillance authority — expired June 12 after Democrats refused to renew it while Bill Pulte remained as acting DNI.

• Trump linked Clayton's confirmation to unrelated demands: passage of the SAVE America Act voter-ID bill and confirmation of Jamie McDonald as a U.S. Attorney.

• Bill Pulte, currently directing the Federal Housing Finance Agency, has no intelligence experience and was set to formally assume the acting DNI role on June 19.

• Clayton's nomination was meant to succeed outgoing DNI Tulsi Gabbard, who resigned last month citing her husband's cancer diagnosis.

Sources

• NPR — Senate to Proceed With Intel Chief Confirmation Hearing

• ABC News — Trump Suddenly Halts Confirmation Hearing for DNI Pick

• PBS NewsHour — Senate Holds Clayton Hearing Despite Trump Pressure

• The Daily Caller — Tom Cotton Barreling Ahead With Clayton Hearing

• Reuters / US News — Trump Calls for Delay of Spy Nominee Confirmation

Also Read

• Newsom DOJ Investigation Escalates After Trump Accusation

• Trump Says Iran Will Never Get Nuclear Weapon as Deal Enters New Stage

• John Healey Resigns as UK Defence Secretary After Spending Clash