Supreme Court's Mixed Term Still Expands Trump's Power
The Supreme Court just handed Donald Trump one of his sharpest defeats of the term. It also just handed him the broadest conception of presidential power the court has ever recognized.
Tuesday's ruling striking down his attempt to end birthright citizenship was decided by a narrow 5-4 margin. Trump called it "too bad for our country" — a notably restrained response by his standards.
A Narrow Loss, a Wide Pattern
The birthright citizenship case closes out a term in which a handful of conservative justices occasionally broke from the majority to check Trump's most aggressive claims. In February, the court struck down his sweeping tariff plan by a 6-3 margin, including two of his own appointees.
In December, a different conservative grouping blocked deployment of National Guard troops to Chicago over local officials' objections.
Trump reacted to the tariff ruling with open fury, calling three conservative justices "lapdogs." His reaction Tuesday was comparatively muted.
📰 Read Also: Trump Wins Agency Case but Loses Elsewhere
The Wins Are Structural
Beneath the headline losses sits a longer list of rulings that expanded executive authority in ways that will outlast this presidency. On Monday, the court's six conservatives ruled Trump can dismiss members of independent regulatory agencies over policy disagreements alone — carving out only the Federal Reserve as an exception.
"This is a very strong, very conservative court with the broadest conception of presidential power that we have ever seen," said Kate Shaw, a law professor at the University of Pennsylvania.
📰 Read Also: Alito Fires Back at Sotomayor From the Bench After Asylum Ruling
Immigration and Elections Tilted in Trump's Favor
The court upheld Trump's revocation of temporary protected status for Haitian and Syrian immigrants and made asylum claims harder to pursue by requiring physical presence on US soil. On election law, it loosened campaign finance limits — a decision that favors the cash-flush national Republican Party over its indebted Democratic counterpart heading into the midterms.
In April, the same six-justice conservative bloc struck down a key Voting Rights Act provision on racial gerrymandering, opening the door for Republican-controlled states to redraw House districts.
📰 Read Also: Trump's DOJ Has Found Little Evidence of Widespread Voter Fraud
An Unfinished Judicial Legacy
Trump named three of the court's nine justices during his first term. Even so, this term shows those appointees are willing to break from him on the most legally novel claims — while the broader conservative bloc continues handing him and future presidents durable structural power.
With speculation swirling about a possible retirement among the court's senior conservatives, Trump's imprint on the judiciary may not be finished yet.
TL;DR
- Supreme Court struck down Trump's birthright citizenship order 5-4, his sharpest defeat this term
- Conservative justices also blocked his tariff plan and a National Guard deployment to Chicago
- The court expanded presidential control over independent federal agencies, excluding the Fed
- Rulings on asylum, TPS, and campaign finance broadly favored Trump's agenda
- Voting Rights Act ruling lets GOP-controlled states redraw more House districts
Read More
You might also like
Politics & World News Editor
James Mitchell has covered US and UK politics for over a decade, with a focus on elections, foreign policy, and Capitol Hill. He breaks down complex political stories into clear, fast analysis.
